The VORG’s 2016 “Manager of the Year” Awards

Tuesday afternoon will see the continuation of the 2016 MLB award period, with the AL and NL Managers of the Year being announced.  These awards are usually given to the skipper of a team that exceeds its preseason expectations.

At the VORG, we don’t think that’s true to the spirit of the word “manager”.  We want to see tangible evidence of … well, managing!  We want our managers to order bunt and stolen base attempts.  We want them to have to manipulate a LOT of players during the course of the year, because its EASY to pilot a squad with little in-season turnover.  We want our managers to need new spikes from walking to and from the pitchers mound to get a fresh arm.  We want them to WORK!

Thus, we present our unique version of the award.  Each team’s managers were ranked within their respective league in such categories as relief appearances, sac bunt attempts, intentional walks given, etc.  The “best” in each category received “1” ranking point, the worst received “15” ranking points.  Total them all up, and the skipper with the lowest overall number is that league’s VORG MOTY.

Here’s some explanations for the categories:

  • SBA: Stolen base attempts.  Most base-stealers do NOT have a green light.  The manager is responsible for initiating the attempt.
  • PH: Pinch-hit plate appearance.  Does a manager use his bench to get the supposed right batter in the game at the right time?
  • Chal.: Challenges.  Some managers put the video review folks through their paces.
  • Def. Shifts: How often did you see the third baseman perched at second base, with the shortstop covering the entire left side of the infield? How many plate appearances saw a defensive shift employed by the manager/team?
  • Def. Sub.: How often did the manager swap in a replacement on defense?
  • POs: Pitchouts. Did the manager try and guess when the opposing team was running?
  • PR: Pinch-runners used.  Does the manager have an Andrew Romine (17 pinch-running appearances in 2016) on his roster, and does he use him at an opportune moment?
  • Att Sac.: Sacrifices attempted.  It doesn’t matter if the attempt succeeded or not.  Did the manager at least try?
  • IBB: Intentional walks.  Some managers eschew this tactic.  Others love it and use it often.
  • Rel.: Relief appearances.  How many times did the manager (have to) make that roughly 75-foot stroll to the mound, raise one arm, take the ball from the pitcher, pat said pitcher on the ass, and greet the new moundsman.
  • Def. Lineups: Total unique starting defensive lineups (exclusive of pitchers).  Some skippers constantly tinker with their lineup (not always by choice).  Some move various players around the diamond.  This quantifies which pilots moved the chess pieces the most.
  • Batting Orders: Total unique batting orders (exclusive of pitchers).
  • TOT: The sum of all the “Rk” columns.  The lower the number, the more managing done.

Here are the results (with data sources above the categories).

In the American League, the Angels’ long-time skipper Mike Scioscia came in first place with 51 points. Scioscia finished first in two categories (defensive substitutions, pitchouts) and second in two others (relief appearances, pinch-runners). Houston’s A.J. Hinch finished second (again) with 68 points, leading the league in one category (defensive shifts). Third place went to Rays’ manager Kevin Cash, who led the league with 137 different defensive lineups used during the year.

The award in the National League goes to the manager who won it in 2014, the Pirates’ Clint Hurdle. He only led in defensive substitutions, but finished second in challenges, defensive shifts and pinch-hitters. Hurdle edged out the Cardinals’ Mike Matheny.  Matheny utilized the most different defensive lineups and batting orders. Coming in third was the Atlanta tandem of Fredi Gonzalez and Brian Snitker. The Atlanta duo only led in attempted sacrifices, but finished no worse than third in three other categories.

Congrats to Scioscia and Hurdle!

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: