From the Twitterverse on Thursday. It started innocently enough:
Rubby De La Rosa will return from the DL tomorrow and start vs. Giants. Only expected to throw around three innings and 50 pitches.
— Nick Piecoro (@nickpiecoro) September 8, 2016
… which led to:
This, of course, means the #sfgiants will face a starter named De La Rosa for the second straight night. @jaysonst https://t.co/LQHdzT0lCc
— Henry Schulman (@hankschulman) September 8, 2016
To which Jayson Stark replied:
Looks like yet another research project for @dianagram https://t.co/TxAJny23sj
— Jayson Stark (@jaysonst) September 9, 2016
So, using the Retrosheet game logs, it turns out that the same team has faced two different pitchers with the same last name in consecutive games nearly 200 times between 1914 and 2015! Of course there are brother combinations in there, like the Perrys, Niekros and Deans, but there are quite a few more without a familial link. Here they are, in team-by-team order:
| DATE | TEAM | GM# | OPP SP |
| 20030508 | ANA | 33 | Jason Davis |
| 20030509 | ANA | 34 | Doug Davis |
| 20090817 | ANA | 116 | David Hernandez |
| 20090818 | ANA | 117 | Fausto Carmona (Roberto Hernandez) |
| 19740522 | BAL | 37 | Jim Perry |
| 19740523 | BAL | 38 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740907 | BAL | 138 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740908 | BAL | 139 | Jim Perry |
| 19890617 | BAL | 64 | Matt Young |
| 19890618 | BAL | 65 | Curt Young |
| 19900727 | BAL | 98 | Storm Davis |
| 19900728 | BAL | 99 | Mark Davis |
| 20010621 | BAL | 71 | Kip Wells |
| 20010622 | BAL | 72 | David Wells |
| 19160627 | BOS | 61 | Jing Johnson |
| 19160628 | BOS | 62 | Walter Johnson |
| 19170428 | BOS | 12 | Walter Johnson |
| 19170430 | BOS | 13 | Jing Johnson |
| 19250909 | BOS | 133 | Hank Johnson |
| 19250911 | BOS | 134 | Walter Johnson |
| 19740513 | BOS | 32 | Jim Perry |
| 19740514 | BOS | 33 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740622 | BOS | 65 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740622 | BOS | 66 | Jim Perry |
| 19740627 | BOS | 70 | Jim Perry |
| 19740628 | BOS | 71 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740911 | BOS | 142 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740912 | BOS | 143 | Jim Perry |
| 19750430 | BOS | 16 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19750501 | BOS | 17 | Jim Perry |
| 19340621 | BRO | 60 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340622 | BRO | 61 | Paul Dean |
| 19340921 | BRO | 144 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340921 | BRO | 145 | Paul Dean |
| 19350824 | BRO | 117 | Paul Dean |
| 19350825 | BRO | 118 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350825 | BRO | 119 | Paul Dean |
| 19200530 | BSN | 34 | Sherry Smith |
| 19200531 | BSN | 35 | George Smith |
| 19320823 | BSN | 126 | Syl Johnson |
| 19320824 | BSN | 127 | Si Johnson |
| 19380728 | BSN | 85 | Peaches Davis |
| 19380729 | BSN | 86 | Curt Davis |
| 19740427 | CAL | 20 | Jim Perry |
| 19740428 | CAL | 21 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740507 | CAL | 29 | Jim Perry |
| 19740508 | CAL | 30 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19160628 | CHA | 61 | Stan Coveleski |
| 19160629 | CHA | 62 | Harry Coveleski |
| 19160802 | CHA | 101 | Jing Johnson |
| 19160804 | CHA | 102 | Walter Johnson |
| 19270728 | CHA | 99 | Walter Johnson |
| 19270729 | CHA | 100 | Jing Johnson |
| 19740611 | CHA | 54 | Jim Perry |
| 19740612 | CHA | 55 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19900905 | CHA | 135 | Mel Stottlemyre |
| 19900907 | CHA | 136 | Todd Stottlemyre |
| 20060510 | CHA | 33 | Ervin Santana |
| 20060512 | CHA | 34 | Johan Santana |
| 19210719 | CHN | 82 | Sherry Smith |
| 19210720 | CHN | 83 | George Smith |
| 19340605 | CHN | 45 | Paul Dean |
| 19340606 | CHN | 46 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340812 | CHN | 109 | Paul Dean |
| 19340812 | CHN | 110 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350416 | CHN | 1 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350418 | CHN | 2 | Paul Dean |
| 19350809 | CHN | 108 | Paul Dean |
| 19350810 | CHN | 109 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350925 | CHN | 150 | Paul Dean |
| 19350927 | CHN | 151 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19580511 | CHN | 24 | Von McDaniel |
| 19580511 | CHN | 25 | Lindy McDaniel |
| 19680703 | CHN | 77 | Larry Jackson |
| 19680704 | CHN | 78 | Grant Jackson |
| 19680914 | CHN | 152 | Larry Jackson |
| 19680915 | CHN | 153 | Grant Jackson |
| 19880820 | CHN | 121 | Zane Smith |
| 19880821 | CHN | 122 | Pete Smith |
| 19960430 | CHN | 27 | Alan Benes |
| 19960501 | CHN | 28 | Andy Benes |
| 20020506 | CHN | 30 | Travis Smith |
| 20020507 | CHN | 31 | Bud Smith |
| 19340708 | CIN | 72 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340708 | CIN | 73 | Paul Dean |
| 19340828 | CIN | 124 | Cy Moore |
| 19340828 | CIN | 125 | Euel Moore |
| 19340928 | CIN | 150 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340929 | CIN | 151 | Paul Dean |
| 19340930 | CIN | 152 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350629 | CIN | 65 | Paul Dean |
| 19350630 | CIN | 66 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350731 | CIN | 96 | Paul Dean |
| 19350801 | CIN | 97 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19360723 | CIN | 86 | Bob Smith |
| 19360725 | CIN | 87 | Al Smith |
| 19670519 | CIN | 36 | Larry Jackson |
| 19670520 | CIN | 37 | Grant Jackson |
| 19670730 | CIN | 104 | Joe Niekro |
| 19670731 | CIN | 105 | Phil Niekro |
| 19750921 | CIN | 156 | Phil Niekro |
| 19750922 | CIN | 157 | Joe Niekro |
| 19800706 | CIN | 80 | Joe Niekro |
| 19800710 | CIN | 81 | Phil Niekro |
| 19821003 | CIN | 162 | Joe Niekro |
| 19830404 | CIN | 1 | Phil Niekro |
| 19870928 | CIN | 156 | Zane Smith |
| 19870929 | CIN | 157 | Pete Smith |
| 19880422 | CIN | 17 | Zane Smith |
| 19880424 | CIN | 18 | Pete Smith |
| 20020810 | CIN | 115 | Robert Joseph Jones |
| 20020811 | CIN | 116 | Robert Mitchell Jones |
| 19630922 | CLE | 156 | Don Lee |
| 19630922 | CLE | 157 | Mike Lee |
| 19900419 | CLE | 8 | Pascual Perez |
| 19900421 | CLE | 9 | Melido Perez |
| 19960805 | CLE | 112 | David Wells |
| 19960806 | CLE | 113 | Bob Wells |
| 19990914 | CLE | 144 | Ramon Martinez |
| 19990915 | CLE | 145 | Pedro Martinez |
| 20000429 | CLE | 20 | Ramon Martinez |
| 20000430 | CLE | 21 | Pedro Martinez |
| 19960820 | COL | 126 | Alan Benes |
| 19960821 | COL | 127 | Andy Benes |
| 19960830 | COL | 136 | Alan Benes |
| 19960831 | COL | 137 | Andy Benes |
| 20000706 | COL | 82 | Russ Ortiz |
| 20000707 | COL | 83 | Ramon Ortiz |
| 20100822 | COL | 123 | Daniel Hudson |
| 20100823 | COL | 124 | Tim Hudson |
| 19160831 | DET | 128 | Allen Russell |
| 19160902 | DET | 129 | Reb Russell |
| 19420529 | DET | 45 | Al Smith |
| 19420530 | DET | 46 | Eddie Smith |
| 19740518 | DET | 33 | Jim Perry |
| 19740519 | DET | 34 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19750422 | DET | 9 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19750423 | DET | 10 | Jim Perry |
| 19850918 | DET | 145 | Phil Niekro |
| 19850919 | DET | 146 | Joe Niekro |
| 19850924 | DET | 151 | Phil Niekro |
| 19850925 | DET | 152 | Joe Niekro |
| 20050717 | DET | 90 | Runelvys Hernandez |
| 20050718 | DET | 91 | Orlando Hernandez |
| 20060528 | DET | 50 | Jason Johnson |
| 20060529 | DET | 51 | Randy Johnson |
| 20000703 | FLO | 83 | Robert Joseph Jones |
| 20000704 | FLO | 84 | Robert Mitchell Jones |
| 20050808 | FLO | 110 | Sun-Woo Kim |
| 20050808 | FLO | 111 | Byung-Hyun Kim |
| 19650627 | HOU | 74 | Al Jackson |
| 19650628 | HOU | 75 | Larry Jackson |
| 19750620 | HOU | 70 | Tom Carroll |
| 19750621 | HOU | 71 | Clay Carroll |
| 19870923 | HOU | 151 | Zane Smith |
| 19870924 | HOU | 152 | Pete Smith |
| 19880412 | HOU | 6 | Zane Smith |
| 19880413 | HOU | 7 | Pete Smith |
| 19890404 | HOU | 1 | Zane Smith |
| 19890405 | HOU | 2 | Pete Smith |
| 19890623 | HOU | 72 | Pete Smith |
| 19890624 | HOU | 73 | Zane Smith |
| 19910512 | HOU | 29 | Bryn Smith |
| 19910514 | HOU | 30 | Zane Smith |
| 19910728 | HOU | 97 | Zane Smith |
| 19910729 | HOU | 98 | Bryn Smith |
| 19930925 | HOU | 155 | Pedro Martinez |
| 19930926 | HOU | 156 | Ramon Martinez |
| 19960825 | HOU | 131 | Alan Benes |
| 19960826 | HOU | 132 | Andy Benes |
| 19740601 | KCA | 48 | Jim Perry |
| 19740602 | KCA | 49 | Gaylord Perry |
| 20090831 | KCA | 131 | Gio Gonzalez |
| 20090901 | KCA | 132 | Edgar Gonzalez |
| 19680903 | LAN | 139 | Grant Jackson |
| 19680904 | LAN | 140 | Larry Jackson |
| 19710512 | LAN | 34 | George Stone |
| 19710514 | LAN | 35 | Steve Stone |
| 19870912 | LAN | 141 | Zane Smith |
| 19870913 | LAN | 142 | Pete Smith |
| 19890617 | LAN | 66 | Pete Smith |
| 19890618 | LAN | 67 | Zane Smith |
| 19960914 | LAN | 148 | Andy Benes |
| 19960915 | LAN | 149 | Alan Benes |
| 20050902 | LAN | 134 | Sun-Woo Kim |
| 20050903 | LAN | 135 | Byung-Hyun Kim |
| 20050913 | LAN | 144 | Sun-Woo Kim |
| 20050914 | LAN | 145 | Byung-Hyun Kim |
| 20120507 | MIA | 29 | Wandy Rodriguez |
| 20120508 | MIA | 30 | Aneury Rodriguez |
| 20130901 | MIA | 135 | Alex Wood |
| 20130902 | MIA | 136 | Travis Wood |
| 19740416 | MIL | 8 | Jim Perry |
| 19740417 | MIL | 9 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740702 | MIL | 74 | Jim Perry |
| 19740703 | MIL | 75 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740924 | MIL | 156 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19740925 | MIL | 157 | Jim Perry |
| 19750418 | MIL | 8 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19750419 | MIL | 9 | Jim Perry |
| 19740712 | MIN | 89 | Jim Perry |
| 19740713 | MIN | 90 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19850421 | MIN | 12 | Curt Young |
| 19850422 | MIN | 13 | Matt Young |
| 20010627 | MIN | 76 | Kip Wells |
| 20010628 | MIN | 77 | David Wells |
| 20090604 | MIN | 55 | Fausto Carmona (Roberto Hernandez) |
| 20090605 | MIN | 56 | Felix Hernandez |
| 19570809 | MLN | 109 | Lindy McDaniel |
| 19570810 | MLN | 110 | Von McDaniel |
| 19630801 | MLN | 109 | Larry Jackson |
| 19630802 | MLN | 110 | Al Jackson |
| 19830714 | MON | 85 | Joe Niekro |
| 19830715 | MON | 86 | Phil Niekro |
| 19890506 | MON | 30 | Zane Smith |
| 19890507 | MON | 31 | Pete Smith |
| 19320524 | NY1 | 30 | Jumbo Elliott |
| 19320525 | NY1 | 31 | Hal Elliott |
| 19340626 | NY1 | 64 | Paul Dean |
| 19340627 | NY1 | 65 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340823 | NY1 | 119 | Paul Dean |
| 19340824 | NY1 | 120 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340916 | NY1 | 140 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340916 | NY1 | 141 | Paul Dean |
| 19350515 | NY1 | 23 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350515 | NY1 | 24 | Paul Dean |
| 19350724 | NY1 | 88 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350725 | NY1 | 89 | Paul Dean |
| 19430912 | NY1 | 134 | Red Barrett |
| 19430914 | NY1 | 135 | Dick Barrett |
| 19570820 | NY1 | 122 | Von McDaniel |
| 19570821 | NY1 | 123 | Lindy McDaniel |
| 19160614 | NYA | 48 | Harry Coveleski |
| 19160615 | NYA | 49 | Stan Coveleski |
| 19410915 | NYA | 147 | Al Smith |
| 19410917 | NYA | 148 | Eddie Smith |
| 19420604 | NYA | 44 | Eddie Smith |
| 19420605 | NYA | 45 | Al Smith |
| 19420719 | NYA | 89 | Eddie Smith |
| 19420721 | NYA | 90 | Al Smith |
| 19680714 | NYN | 88 | Grant Jackson |
| 19680715 | NYN | 89 | Larry Jackson |
| 19760429 | NYN | 19 | Phil Niekro |
| 19760430 | NYN | 20 | Joe Niekro |
| 19780513 | NYN | 34 | Joe Niekro |
| 19780517 | NYN | 35 | Phil Niekro |
| 19880502 | NYN | 23 | Zane Smith |
| 19880503 | NYN | 24 | Pete Smith |
| 19880715 | NYN | 89 | Zane Smith |
| 19880716 | NYN | 90 | Pete Smith |
| 19890425 | NYN | 18 | Zane Smith |
| 19890426 | NYN | 19 | Pete Smith |
| 19890501 | NYN | 23 | Zane Smith |
| 19890502 | NYN | 24 | Pete Smith |
| 20050929 | NYN | 159 | Sun-Woo Kim |
| 20050930 | NYN | 160 | Byung-Hyun Kim |
| 20100801 | NYN | 105 | Daniel Hudson |
| 20100802 | NYN | 106 | Tim Hudson |
| 19740503 | OAK | 22 | Jim Perry |
| 19740504 | OAK | 23 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19980515 | OAK | 39 | Frank Castillo |
| 19980516 | OAK | 40 | Carlos Castillo |
| 20000415 | OAK | 11 | Pedro Martinez |
| 20000416 | OAK | 12 | Ramon Martinez |
| 20060608 | OAK | 60 | Jason Johnson |
| 20060609 | OAK | 61 | Randy Johnson |
| 20070919 | OAK | 154 | Felix Hernandez |
| 20070921 | OAK | 155 | Fausto Carmona (Roberto Hernandez) |
| 19251003 | PHA | 153 | Hank Johnson |
| 19260413 | PHA | 1 | Walter Johnson |
| 19240702 | PHI | 66 | Jesse Barnes |
| 19240704 | PHI | 67 | Virgil Barnes |
| 19250701 | PHI | 67 | Virgil Barnes |
| 19250703 | PHI | 68 | Jesse Barnes |
| 19340616 | PHI | 50 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340617 | PHI | 51 | Paul Dean |
| 19350511 | PHI | 17 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350511 | PHI | 18 | Paul Dean |
| 19350620 | PHI | 52 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19350621 | PHI | 53 | Paul Dean |
| 19360613 | PHI | 55 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19360614 | PHI | 56 | Paul Dean |
| 19570626 | PHI | 67 | Lindy McDaniel |
| 19570627 | PHI | 68 | Von McDaniel |
| 19640614 | PHI | 53 | Al Jackson |
| 19640616 | PHI | 54 | Larry Jackson |
| 19740810 | PHI | 114 | Phil Niekro |
| 19740811 | PHI | 115 | Joe Niekro |
| 19770823 | PHI | 123 | Phil Niekro |
| 19770824 | PHI | 124 | Joe Niekro |
| 19800717 | PHI | 84 | Joe Niekro |
| 19800718 | PHI | 85 | Phil Niekro |
| 19830427 | PHI | 16 | Phil Niekro |
| 19830429 | PHI | 17 | Joe Niekro |
| 19880507 | PHI | 27 | Zane Smith |
| 19880508 | PHI | 28 | Pete Smith |
| 19880719 | PHI | 93 | Zane Smith |
| 19880720 | PHI | 94 | Pete Smith |
| 19960420 | PHI | 16 | Alan Benes |
| 19960421 | PHI | 17 | Andy Benes |
| 19320415 | PIT | 4 | Syl Johnson |
| 19320416 | PIT | 5 | Si Johnson |
| 19340417 | PIT | 1 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340418 | PIT | 2 | Paul Dean |
| 19340925 | PIT | 146 | Dizzy Dean |
| 19340926 | PIT | 147 | Paul Dean |
| 19680909 | PIT | 145 | Larry Jackson |
| 19680911 | PIT | 146 | Grant Jackson |
| 19780824 | PIT | 125 | Phil Niekro |
| 19780825 | PIT | 126 | Joe Niekro |
| 19790429 | PIT | 18 | Joe Niekro |
| 19790501 | PIT | 19 | Phil Niekro |
| 19790712 | PIT | 83 | Joe Niekro |
| 19790713 | PIT | 84 | Phil Niekro |
| 19820502 | PIT | 20 | Joe Niekro |
| 19820503 | PIT | 21 | Phil Niekro |
| 19890512 | PIT | 32 | Zane Smith |
| 19890513 | PIT | 33 | Pete Smith |
| 19960415 | PIT | 12 | Alan Benes |
| 19960416 | PIT | 13 | Andy Benes |
| 19960924 | PIT | 157 | Andy Benes |
| 19960925 | PIT | 158 | Alan Benes |
| 20020719 | PIT | 96 | Bud Smith |
| 20020720 | PIT | 97 | Travis Smith |
| 20080430 | PIT | 27 | Oliver Perez |
| 20080501 | PIT | 28 | Odalis Perez |
| 20120610 | PIT | 59 | Bruce Chen |
| 20120612 | PIT | 60 | Wei-Yin Chen |
| 19760514 | SDN | 29 | Paul Reuschel |
| 19760516 | SDN | 30 | Rick Reuschel |
| 19800921 | SDN | 151 | Phil Niekro |
| 19800922 | SDN | 152 | Joe Niekro |
| 19810524 | SDN | 42 | Phil Niekro |
| 19810525 | SDN | 43 | Joe Niekro |
| 19910619 | SDN | 67 | Zane Smith |
| 19910621 | SDN | 68 | Bryn Smith |
| 20000404 | SEA | 1 | Pedro Martinez |
| 20000405 | SEA | 2 | Ramon Martinez |
| 20060628 | SEA | 79 | Edgar Gonzalez |
| 20060629 | SEA | 80 | Enrique Gonzalez |
| 19800601 | SFN | 47 | Joe Niekro |
| 19800602 | SFN | 48 | Phil Niekro |
| 19890414 | SFN | 9 | Zane Smith |
| 19890415 | SFN | 10 | Pete Smith |
| 19910602 | SFN | 50 | Pete Smith |
| 19910604 | SFN | 51 | Zane Smith |
| 20050924 | SFN | 154 | Sun-Woo Kim |
| 20050925 | SFN | 155 | Byung-Hyun Kim |
| 19170624 | SLA | 58 | Harry Coveleski |
| 19170625 | SLA | 59 | Stan Coveleski |
| 19190608 | SLA | 36 | Walter Johnson |
| 19190610 | SLA | 37 | Jing Johnson |
| 19310528 | SLA | 34 | Fay Thomas |
| 19310531 | SLA | 35 | Tommy Thomas |
| 19670527 | SLN | 36 | Grant Jackson |
| 19670528 | SLN | 37 | Larry Jackson |
| 19670924 | SLN | 157 | Phil Niekro |
| 19670926 | SLN | 158 | Joe Niekro |
| 19740516 | SLN | 33 | George Stone |
| 19740517 | SLN | 34 | Steve Stone |
| 19750813 | SLN | 117 | Joe Niekro |
| 19750814 | SLN | 118 | Phil Niekro |
| 19880513 | SLN | 34 | Pete Smith |
| 19880514 | SLN | 35 | Zane Smith |
| 20010616 | SLN | 67 | Kip Wells |
| 20010617 | SLN | 68 | David Wells |
| 20000505 | TBA | 28 | Ramon Martinez |
| 20000506 | TBA | 29 | Pedro Martinez |
| 19740527 | TEX | 45 | Jim Perry |
| 19740528 | TEX | 46 | Gaylord Perry |
| 19860723 | TEX | 95 | Joe Niekro |
| 19860724 | TEX | 96 | Phil Niekro |
| 20000424 | TEX | 19 | Ramon Martinez |
| 20000425 | TEX | 20 | Pedro Martinez |
| 20080522 | TEX | 49 | Livan Hernandez |
| 20080523 | TEX | 50 | Fausto Carmona (Roberto Hernandez) |
| 19890622 | TOR | 71 | Matt Young |
| 19890623 | TOR | 72 | Curt Young |
| 19900718 | TOR | 92 | Matt Young |
| 19900720 | TOR | 93 | Curt Young |
| 20010523 | TOR | 45 | David Wells |
| 20010524 | TOR | 46 | Kip Wells |
| 19160605 | WS1 | 45 | Harry Coveleski |
| 19160608 | WS1 | 46 | Stan Coveleski |
| 19170420 | WS1 | 7 | Jing Johnson |
| 19170421 | WS1 | 8 | Ellis Johnson |